newman: (Default)
[personal profile] newman
(This isn't going to mean a lot to you if you're not in the SCA. Even if you are, it may not mean a lot to you)

A short note came across the wires this morning from Hal Simon (Chairman of the BOD) regarding the invalidation of the reign of the current King and Queen of The Middle because of a 3-day lapse in membership due to some unusual circumstances. At the conclusion of the brief letter, Mr. Simon (as ever) indicates that "Questions, suggestions and comments can be sent to [email address snipped]". This is the note I'm considering sending; do I bother?



Dear Mr. Simon:

Upon reading your recent brief note concerning the invalidation of the reign of Lutr and Tessa, I was struck by the fact that The Board of Directors seems increasingly hidebound, interested in enforcing the letter of our laws, regardless of the cost or of the original intent of those laws. Interest in the S.C.A. from senior members (such as myself) is waning, and The S.C.A. has not been able to increase new member recruitment. My question, suggestion, and comment are

1) Why aren't the Board of Directors focused more on improving the S.C.A. and less on preserving some perceived status quo?

2) Please increase the transparency of our government. Much of the Board's actions are in a sealed Star Chamber.

3) If the Board of Directors does not make some drastic changes in the next few years, the S.C.A. as an entity will cease to exist. It already has largely ceased to exist as an organization I wish to be part of.

Alternative text for #3: If the Board of Directors does not make some drastic changes in the next few years, the S.C.A. as an entity will cease to exist. It is already well on its way to becoming an organization I would not wish to be part of.

Signed,

me, with all the titles and O.P. stuff that apparently makes me worth listening to ;-)

Date: 2008-05-19 11:10 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] baron-steffan.livejournal.com
they're currently getting around the problem with the most egregious and clever rules-hack I've seen in the entire history of the Society
You mean the double crown tournament? What is your reason for so characterizing it?

Date: 2008-05-20 01:28 am (UTC)
jducoeur: (Default)
From: [personal profile] jducoeur
It's not *just* a double Crown Tournament. It's apparently an open secret within the Middle that nobody is supposed to seriously compete in the first one *except* their just-deposed Majesties. Nobody's saying so officially, and I'm quite sure that Palymar will allow anyone who wants to to enter -- but it looks (from this distance) like the whole thing was constructed specifically to give the members of the Kingdom the chance to all step back and let Lutr win. (Indeed, when I first saw the idea proposed on Middlebridge on Saturday, this was quite explicitly the motive.)

*That* is why I call it a gigantic rules-hack, and a very clever one. I may be misinterpreting, but that's how I read the various messages I've seen...

Profile

newman: (Default)
newman

March 2025

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9 10111213 1415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     

Most Popular Tags

Active Entries

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Feb. 7th, 2026 09:21 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios